Pay vs Performance Disclosure, Table

Pay versus Performance Table

Year	Summary Compensation Table Total for CEO(1)		Compensation Actually Paid to CEO(1,4)		Average Summary Compensation Table Total for Non-CEO NEOs(2)		Average Compensation Actually Paid to Non-CEO NEOs(2,4)		Value of Initial Fixed $100 Investment Based On:		Net Income (In $M)		Pre-Tax Margin
Year	Summary Compensation Table Total for CEO(1)		Compensation Actually Paid to CEO(1,4)				Average Compensation Actually Paid to Non-CEO NEOs(2,4)		Total Shareholder Return	Peer Group Total Shareholder Return(3)	Net Income (In $M)		Pre-Tax Margin
2024	$	5,426,566	$	6,219,391	$	1,829,348	$	2,057,545	193.81	201.73	$	73.30	4.60%
2023	$	4,162,926	$	5,062,657	$	1,480,871	$	1,736,423	163.93	161.31	$	30.40	2.70%
2022	$	3,940,313	$	(1,589,146)	$	1,722,672	$	153,723	114.37	117.11	$	162.30	7.60%
2021	$	5,147,655	$	10,064,576	$	2,132,088	$	3,589,953	206.56	123.24	$	323.20	13.10%
2020	$	4,037,845	$	5,933,605	$	1,557,325	$	2,381,666	122.55	94.84	$	154.90	9.50%

(1) Mr. Eppinger was the CEO for 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024.

(2) Messrs. Hisey, Lessack, and John Killea, and Ms. Tara Smith were non-CEO NEOs for 2020, 2021, and 2022. Mr. Hisey, Mr. Lessack, Ms. Smith, and Ms. Giddens were non-CEO NEOs for 2023. Mr. Hisey, Mr. Lessack, Ms. Giddens, and Mr. Rable were non-CEO NEOs for 2024.

(3) Peer Group used in 2024 calculations is the group of companies disclosed in the “Pay Comparator Group” section of the CD&A portion of the 2025 Stewart Information Services Corp. proxy filing, which discusses the companies that were added and removed from the peer group in 2024 and the criteria used to make such determinations.

Peer Group used in 2023 calculations is the group of companies disclosed in the “Pay Comparator Group” section of the CD&A portion of the 2024 Stewart Information Services Corp. proxy filing, which discusses the companies that were added and removed from the peer group in 2023 and the criteria used to make such determinations.

Peer Group used in 2022 calculations, for fiscal year ended December 31, 2022, below:

		American Equity Investment Life Holding Company		MGIC Investment Corporation
		Argo Group International Holdings, Ltd.		Old Republic International Corporation
		CNO Financial Group, Inc.		ProAssurance Corporation
		Employers Holdings, Inc.		Radian Group Inc.
		Enstar Group Limited		RLI Corp.
		First American Financial Corporation		Safety Insurance Group, Inc.
		Hilltop Holdings Inc.		Selective Insurance Group, Inc.
		Horace Mann Educators Corporation		The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.
		James River Group Holdings, Ltd.		United Fire Group, Inc.
		Mercury General Corporation

State Auto Financial Corporation was removed from the 2022 peer group since it was taken private and is no longer publicly traded.

Peer Group used in 2021 calculations, for fiscal year ended December 31, 2021, below:

		American Equity Investment Life Holding Company		MGIC Investment Corporation
		American National Insurance Company		Old Republic International Corporation
		Argo Group International Holdings, Ltd.		ProAssurance Corporation
		CNO Financial Group, Inc.		Radian Group Inc.
		Employers Holdings, Inc.		RLI Corp.
		Enstar Group Limited		Safety Insurance Group, Inc.
		First American Financial Corporation		Selective Insurance Group, Inc.
		Hilltop Holdings Inc.		State Auto Financial Corporation
		Horace Mann Educators Corporation		The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.
		James River Group Holdings, Ltd.		United Fire Group, Inc.
		Mercury General Corporation

National General Holdings Corporation was removed from the 2021 peer group, as it was acquired and is no longer publicly traded.

Peer Group used in 2020 calculations, for fiscal year ended December 31, 2020, below:

		American Equity Investment Life Holding Company		MGIC Investment Corporation
		American National Insurance Company		National General Holdings Corporation
		Argo Group International Holdings, Ltd.		Old Republic International Corporation
		CNO Financial Group, Inc.		ProAssurance Corporation
		Employers Holdings, Inc.		Radian Group Inc.
		Enstar Group Limited		RLI Corp.
		First American Financial Corporation		Safety Insurance Group, Inc.
		Hilltop Holdings Inc.		Selective Insurance Group, Inc.
		Horace Mann Educators Corporation		State Auto Financial Corporation
		James River Group Holdings, Ltd.		The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.
		Mercury General Corporation		United Fire Group, Inc.

(4) The following table reflects the adjustments made to the Summary Compensation Table to determine Compensation Actually Paid.

	2024				2023				2022				2021				2020
Adjustments	CEO		Average non-CEO NEOs		CEO		Average non-CEO NEOs		CEO		Average non-CEO NEOs		CEO		Average non-CEO NEOs		CEO		Average non-CEO NEOs
Summary Compensation Table Total	$	5,426,566	$	1,829,348	$	4,162,926	$	1,480,871	$	3,940,313	$	1,722,672	$	5,147,655	$	2,132,088	$	4,037,845	$	1,557,325
(-) Grant Date Fair Value of Stock Awards Granted in FY	$	2,489,672	$	764,037	$	2,144,190	$	602,729	$	2,144,198	$	786,920	$	1,583,464	$	533,345	$	764,982	$	197,905
(-) Grant Date Fair Value of Option Awards Granted in FY	$	0	$	0	$	0	$	0	$	0	$	58,070	$	406,440	$	120,859	$	763,085	$	197,429
(+) Stock Awards Granted in CFY and Unvested as of end of CFY	$	2,734,830	$	839,272	$	3,080,733	$	865,990	$	1,422,695	$	522,129	$	2,371,330	$	798,715	$	930,446	$	240,712
(+) Option Awards Granted in CFY and Unvested as of end of CFY	$	0	$	0	$	0	$	0	$	0	$	0	$	1,254,522	$	373,045	$	2,381,299	$	616,102
(+) Stock Awards Granted in Prior Years and Unvested as of end of CFY	$	436,012	$	118,462	$	(685,382)	$	(141,837)	$	(1,154,548)	$	(334,147)	$	866,847	$	141,439	$	112,081	$	65,028
(+) Option Awards Granted in Prior Years and Unvested as of end of CFY	$	0	$	0	$	221,475	$	51,955	$	(2,806,312)	$	(751,583)	$	2,471,764	$	639,508	$	0	$	0
(+) Stock Awards Granted in Prior Years and Vested during CFY	$	69,646	$	21,558	$	24,358	$	3,704	$	(500,682)	$	(67,164)	$	(1,475)	$	173,892	$	0	$	297,834
(+) Option Awards Granted in Prior Years and Vested during CFY	$	42,009	$	12,942	$	402,738	$	78,469	$	(346,414)	$	(93,194)	$	(56,163)	$	(14,531)	$	0	$	0
= Compensation Actually Paid	$	6,219,391	$	2,057,545	$	5,062,657	$	1,736,423	$	(1,589,146)	$	153,723	$	10,064,576	$	3,589,953	$	5,933,605	$	2,381,666

Peer Group Issuers, Footnote

Peer Group used in 2022 calculations, for fiscal year ended December 31, 2022, below:

		American Equity Investment Life Holding Company		MGIC Investment Corporation
		Argo Group International Holdings, Ltd.		Old Republic International Corporation
		CNO Financial Group, Inc.		ProAssurance Corporation
		Employers Holdings, Inc.		Radian Group Inc.
		Enstar Group Limited		RLI Corp.
		First American Financial Corporation		Safety Insurance Group, Inc.
		Hilltop Holdings Inc.		Selective Insurance Group, Inc.
		Horace Mann Educators Corporation		The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.
		James River Group Holdings, Ltd.		United Fire Group, Inc.
		Mercury General Corporation

State Auto Financial Corporation was removed from the 2022 peer group since it was taken private and is no longer publicly traded.

Peer Group used in 2021 calculations, for fiscal year ended December 31, 2021, below:

		American Equity Investment Life Holding Company		MGIC Investment Corporation
		American National Insurance Company		Old Republic International Corporation
		Argo Group International Holdings, Ltd.		ProAssurance Corporation
		CNO Financial Group, Inc.		Radian Group Inc.
		Employers Holdings, Inc.		RLI Corp.
		Enstar Group Limited		Safety Insurance Group, Inc.
		First American Financial Corporation		Selective Insurance Group, Inc.
		Hilltop Holdings Inc.		State Auto Financial Corporation
		Horace Mann Educators Corporation		The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.
		James River Group Holdings, Ltd.		United Fire Group, Inc.
		Mercury General Corporation

National General Holdings Corporation was removed from the 2021 peer group, as it was acquired and is no longer publicly traded.

Peer Group used in 2020 calculations, for fiscal year ended December 31, 2020, below:

		American Equity Investment Life Holding Company		MGIC Investment Corporation
		American National Insurance Company		National General Holdings Corporation
		Argo Group International Holdings, Ltd.		Old Republic International Corporation
		CNO Financial Group, Inc.		ProAssurance Corporation
		Employers Holdings, Inc.		Radian Group Inc.
		Enstar Group Limited		RLI Corp.
		First American Financial Corporation		Safety Insurance Group, Inc.
		Hilltop Holdings Inc.		Selective Insurance Group, Inc.
		Horace Mann Educators Corporation		State Auto Financial Corporation
		James River Group Holdings, Ltd.		The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.
		Mercury General Corporation		United Fire Group, Inc.

PEO Total Compensation Amount

^[1]

$ 5,426,566

$ 4,162,926

$ 3,940,313

$ 5,147,655

$ 4,037,845

PEO Actually Paid Compensation Amount

^[1],[2]

6,219,391

5,062,657

(1,589,146)

10,064,576

5,933,605

Non-PEO NEO Average Total Compensation Amount

^[3]

1,829,348

1,480,871

1,722,672

2,132,088

1,557,325

Non-PEO NEO Average Compensation Actually Paid Amount

^[2],[3]

$ 2,057,545

1,736,423

153,723

3,589,953

2,381,666

Compensation Actually Paid vs. Net Income

Compensation Actually Paid vs. Company Selected Measure

Total Shareholder Return Vs Peer Group

Tabular List, Table

Company-selected performance measures

Pre-Tax Margin

Company Total Revenue

Title Segment Operating Revenue

Title Market Share

Diluted EPS

Employee Engagement

Total Shareholder Return Amount

$ 193.81

163.93

114.37

206.56

122.55

Peer Group Total Shareholder Return Amount

^[4]

201.73

161.31

117.11

123.24

94.84

Net Income (Loss)

$ 73.3

$ 30.4

$ 162.3

$ 323.2

$ 154.9

Company Selected Measure Amount

4.6

2.7

7.6

13.1

9.5

PEO Name

Mr. Eppinger

Measure:: 1

Pre-Tax Margin

Measure:: 2

Company Total Revenue

Measure:: 3

Title Segment Operating Revenue

Measure:: 4

Title Market Share

Measure:: 5

Diluted EPS

Measure:: 6

Employee Engagement

PEO [Member]

PEO Total Compensation Amount

$ 5,426,566

$ 4,162,926

$ 3,940,313

$ 5,147,655

$ 4,037,845

PEO Actually Paid Compensation Amount

6,219,391

5,062,657

(1,589,146)

10,064,576

5,933,605

Non-PEO NEO [Member]

Non-PEO NEO Average Total Compensation Amount

1,829,348

1,480,871

1,722,672

2,132,088

1,557,325

Non-PEO NEO Average Compensation Actually Paid Amount

2,057,545

1,736,423

153,723

3,589,953

2,381,666

PEO [Member] | Grant Date Fair Value of Stock Awards Granted in FY [Member]

PEO [Member] | Grant Date Fair Value of Option Awards Granted in FY [Member]

2,489,672

2,144,190

2,144,198

1,583,464

764,982

PEO [Member] | Stock Awards Granted in CFY and Unvested as of end of CFY [Member]

406,440

763,085

PEO [Member] | Option Awards Granted in CFY and Unvested as of end of CFY [Member]

2,734,830

3,080,733

1,422,695

2,371,330

930,446

PEO [Member] | Stock Awards Granted in Prior Years and Unvested as of end of CFY [Member]

1,254,522

2,381,299

PEO [Member] | Option Awards Granted in Prior Years and Unvested as of end of CFY [Member]

436,012

(685,382)

(1,154,548)

866,847

112,081

PEO [Member] | Stock Awards Granted in Prior Years and Vested during CFY [Member]

221,475

(2,806,312)

2,471,764

PEO [Member] | Option Awards Granted in Prior Years and Vested during CFY [Member]

69,646

24,358

(500,682)

(1,475)

Non-PEO NEO [Member] | Grant Date Fair Value of Stock Awards Granted in FY [Member]

42,009

402,738

(346,414)

(56,163)

Non-PEO NEO [Member] | Grant Date Fair Value of Option Awards Granted in FY [Member]

764,037

602,729

786,920

533,345

197,905

Non-PEO NEO [Member] | Stock Awards Granted in CFY and Unvested as of end of CFY [Member]

58,070

120,859

197,429

Non-PEO NEO [Member] | Option Awards Granted in CFY and Unvested as of end of CFY [Member]

839,272

865,990

522,129

798,715

240,712

Non-PEO NEO [Member] | Stock Awards Granted in Prior Years and Unvested as of end of CFY [Member]

373,045

616,102

Non-PEO NEO [Member] | Option Awards Granted in Prior Years and Unvested as of end of CFY [Member]

118,462

(141,837)

(334,147)

141,439

65,028

Non-PEO NEO [Member] | Stock Awards Granted in Prior Years and Vested during CFY [Member]

51,955

(751,583)

639,508

Non-PEO NEO [Member] | Option Awards Granted in Prior Years and Vested during CFY [Member]

21,558

3,704

(67,164)

173,892

297,834